-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 7
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
One and a half new bugs with 2.987 OSS #27
Comments
Oh, and the Downloaded list also doesn't show anything after a successful download. |
Also on such old OS versions, the IDK why the I just realized that there's also something wrong \ messed up with the I decided to share this information, even tho I don't think that @gzsombor will even read this, let alone try to fix the issues, or anyone else for that matter, as it seems like no one that can code in Java\Kotlin cares about this app\project unfortunately... OP, you should try to grab the crash log, I use Scoop by TacoTheDank, so install, "activate" it and paste the LogCat here if you want, else no-one can figure out why is crashing on only one of your devices while using the search functionality, try also the Correction: I use Scoop on A.8.0.0 and newer, not on older OS version, because it might require A.5.0+, but it actually doesn't capture anything there, at least on SGS4, on SGS3 with A.4.3 I actually use LogCat Extreme Pro [4.0+] and filter by app, so I don't "capture" unnecessary\unrelated logs. |
Also 2.987 crashes when I open video-comments. On 2.986 an error occurs... Setup of most broken installation : |
Well, I've done a bunch more testing with 2.985 OSS (f-droid), 2.986 OSS (f-droid) and 2.987 OSS (github), The broken Bookmark issue definitely is with 2.987 and affects both my devices. I assume the missing Download list is likewise, but didn't test it (as I rarely download anyway). However, the Search crash is more complicated. I'm 99% sure it used to work fine on both devices, yet now all three versions of SkyTube Legacy have the same crash on my GT-P5100 with Android 4.2.2. But the crash actually doesn't happen on the first search after installation or after clearing the app data via the App Manager, only on subsequent searches. Interestingly, the Enter URL dialogue which also brings up the keyboard for text input, works just fine, no crash. Search has a history though, so maybe this crash relates somehow to that feature? Anyway, I don't know of anything that's changed on this device recently such that all three versions of SkyTube Legacy now crash using the Search function. I did download the Scoop app to help diagnose the crash issue, but sadly, this now requires Android 5.0 or higher. I couldn't locate a previous version that supports Android 4.0+, though that's apparently what this app originally did. So after much trial and error (other methods researched on the 'net didn't work), I figured I could get some kind of debugging information using : Now I just need to sift through this 6.5MB file to see if it has anything useful regarding this crash event ... Joe. |
@j-ds-au apologies\sorry for the confusion, I've edited my comment above, look for the "correction" text at the end. Scoop was originally an Xposed Module by another dev., fortunately TacoTheDank forked it and made it standalone, unfortunately it has issues and it's completely useless and not even installable on such "ancient" OS vers. |
Thanks, drogga. As none of my present devices are rooted, LogCat Extreme Pro isn't an option at this time. However, I did manage to extract the events from the log, of around the time of the last crash, below. Bug report log extract (spoiler toggle)
Some other details ... Joe. |
That app can also be "activated" via adb shell command, I just mentioned that I'm using it on rooted system, so I didn't have to activate it. |
Thanks for the detailed logs, based on the stack trace, the Android, which you have on your device, comes from between November and September of 2013, I found in TypedArray.java:464 and View.java:3752, so it seems, that in such an old Android versions, the minHeight attribute (or any dimensional attribute) can't refer to another attribute. It seems, that in SkyTube, there are 4 places, where such a reference is used:
Probably, the 4th was the trigger for your crash. |
Thanks, Zsombor! I'm glad you could make sense of those logs! And I agree that no. 4 seems the most likely place, as entering a URL works just fine. Interestingly, my other device, which has an even older version of Android (4.1.2 as compared to 4.2.2), doesn't suffer this crash. Joe. |
Hi again, Zsombor. Looking again at the bug report log, I see that the crashing SkyTube Legacy app had a Process ID of 6817. So I've created a revised log extract based on this PID, below. Revised log extract (spoiler toggle)
<3>[ 1952.843261] C0 [ kworker/u:1] binder: release proc 6817, transaction 84147, not freed ------ SYSTEM LOG (logcat -v threadtime -d *:v) ------ 08-22 16:02:20.814 6817 6833 W dalvikvm: Unable to resolve superclass of Lj$/util/stream/R0; (489) ------ EVENT LOG (logcat -b events -v threadtime -d *:v) ------ 08-22 16:02:18.236 470 814 I am_proc_start: [0,6817,10177,free.rm.skytube.legacy.oss,activity,free.rm.skytube.legacy.oss/free.rm.skytube.gui.activities.MainActivity] Additionally, I tested this Search crash issue on my olde Coby MID9762 with Android 4.0.3 and my Samsung GT-N8010 with Android 4.4.2 (November 2014 Kernel). The MID9762 worked fine, but the GT-N8010 crashed on the second use of the Search function, just like the GT-P5100 did earlier. My two oldest devices are actually working fine, yet my two somewhat newer devices are not. Might there be something peculiar to Samsung that's causing the issue? All devices are unrooted and running their latest stock firmware. Joe. |
After upgrading (via uninstall then install) from 2.985 OSS (f-droid) to 2.987 OSS (github), I encountered one and a half bugs :
Setup of most broken installation :
Android version: 4.2.2
Is Your device rooted? No
Do You use Tor or any VPN service with your device? No
App source: GitHub
App Version: v. 2.987
App Flavour: Legacy
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: