Verifiable Credential Authentication via OpenID Connect

The following document outlines verifiable credential authentication via OpenID Connect.

The aim of this document is to describe how a standard OpenID provider (OP) can be extended to support verifiable credential authentication. With this support, a relying party (RP) is able to request this method of authentication to harness the power of verifiable credentials.

Background

Verifiable credentials are a pending W3C standard that defines a data model for expressing credentials in a verifiable way digitally.

A verifiable credential ecosystem, breaks down in the following way

Note - the above diagram originated from the Verifiable Credential specification

A verifiable credential is essentially a set of one or more claims that is made by an issuer about a subject/holder that when presented to a verifier, its authorship and in most cases ownership can be proven.

The integration this document defines is how holders of verifiable credentials can leverage these to authenticate with parties. Note, how the holder became in possession of supported verifiable credentials is out of scope for this integration.

Like any new technology there is adoption required of new concepts, this particular integration aims to provide an easy integration path that allows parties to start leveraging the power of verifiable credentials for user authentication in a non-disruptive fashion. This is achieved by extending the vastly popular OpenID Connect family of specifications.

In reference to the above diagram. A supporting OP will act as the verifier on behalf of a RP for a verifiable credentials presentation. This mode of integration means RP's that already support OIDC only have to extend their support to making ACAPy VC-AuthN based OIDC requests to a supported OP, rather than adding full support for verifiable credential interactions directly. The holder will use an IdentityWallet (IW) mobile app to store their verifiable credentials and manage presentation requests from verifiers.

Abbreviations

Below are some abbreviations that are used throughout this document.

Term	Definition
VC	Verifiable Credential
VC-AuthN	Verifiable Credential Authentication
OIDC	OpenID Connect
OP	OpenID Provider
UserAgent	Software acting on behalf of the user, in this example usually the web browser
IdentityWallet	The wallet application that contains the users verifiable credentials (Maps to the Holder/Subject role in reference to the W3C standard)
RP	The relying party requesting authentication from an OP
VC-AuthN Request	A request made by a RP to a OP requesting verifiable credential authentication
VC-AuthN Response	A response to a VC-AuthN Request that is made by an OP and sent to an RP
VC Presentation Request	A request made by an OP to an IdentityWallet requesting a verifiable credential presentation
VC Presentation Response	A response made by an IdentityWallet presenting the credentials requested back to a OP
ID Token	An OIDC identity token emitted by an OP on successful authentication
IAM	Identity and Access Management
DIDComm	An emerging messaging protocol based on DID infrastructure, see here for more details
IW	IdentityWallet
VC-PR	Verifiable Credential Presentation Request
VC-P	Verifiable Credential Presentation

Component Diagram

Below depicts a high level component diagram this integration features

+--------+                                   +--------+
|        |                                   |        |
|        |------(1) VC-AuthN Request-------->|        |
|        |                                   |        |
|        |                                   |        |                        +--------+
|        |                                   |        |---(2) DIDComm VC-PR--->|        |
|   RP   |                                   |   OP/  |                        |  IW/   |
|        |                                   |Verifier|                        | Holder |
|        |                                   |        |<--(3) DIDComm VC-P ----|        |
|        |                                   |        |                        +--------+
|        |                                   |        |
|        |<-----(4) VC-AuthN Response--------|        |
|        |                                   |        |
+--------+                                   +--------+

Note - The above diagram has been modified from this diagram from the OpenID Connect specification.

As the above diagram indicates, DID Communication (DIDComm) is used as the messaging protocol between the OP and IW. DIDComm, is an emerging messaging protocol that is being incubated and developed under the Hyperledger Aries Project with much of the current protocol documentation residing under the Aries RFC repository. This messaging protocol is used as the medium for the OP to communicate with the IW.

Integration Sequence Diagram

Below is the general sequence diagram that describes the flow.

There are two main ways the interactions between the actors of VC-AuthN will be used

The UserAgent and IdentityWallet are co-located on the same device i.e a user is in a browser session (the user agent) where a deep link is invoked by the user agent causing the phone to open the IdentityWallet (another app on the users phone). After responding to the request the phone is redirected back to the UserAgent.
The UserAgent and IdentityWallet are not co-located, i.e the user is browsing on a desktop computer, a VC presentation request is rendered in browser via a QR code. The IdentityWallet scans the QR code and responds to the challenge. The desktop browsing session then automatically updates into the authenticated session.

In the above diagram under the OAuth Flow group, both the Implicit Flow and Authorization Flow defined by OAuth is described for completeness. However, it is widely regarded as industry best practise that Authorization Flow is used in all cases where possible.

VC-AuthN OP

The below section defines the extensions required to a standard OP, that is required to support VC-AuthN.

Requirements

A VC-AuthN enabled OP's requirements can be described by the following.

Receive and validate VC-AuthN requests (an extended OpenID Connect authentication request).
Generate verifiable credential presentation request from the VC-AuthN OIDC request.
Present verifiable credential presentation requests to the user agent in a form consumable by the IdentityWallet (e.g via a QR code or deep-link).
Handle verifiable credential presentations sent from the IdentityWallet back to the OP.
Validate verifiable credential presentations
Map verifiable credential presentation to OpenID Connect ID tokens.
Return the ID token back to the RP.
Expose an API that allows RPs to manage verifiable credential presentation request configurations.

OIDC VC-AuthN Request

In order to request an OP to generate a VC-AuthN request, the standard OpenID Connect authentication request sent to the provider must be extended in the following ways.

In the scopes in addition to the openid scope the vc_authn scope must also be included
An additional query parameter of pres_req_conf_id must be included where the value is an identifier resolvable by the the OP to a verifiable presentation request configuration outlined here

Example request

POST connect/authorize HTTP/1.1
Host: op-server.com
Content-Type: application/x-www-form-urlencoded
client_id=<rp-client-id>
&client_secret=<rp-client-secret>
&scope="openid vc_authn"
&pres_req_conf_id=<pres_req_conf_id>
&response_type=<oauth-response-type>
&redirect_uri=rp.domain.com/redirect

Note: client_id, client_secret, response_type, redirect_uri, scope are all standard parameters defined in the OpendID Connect authentication request.

VC Presentation Request Configuration

With VC-AuthN the RP instructs the OP on what to authenticate from the end user, the pres_req_conf_id parameter present in the request is used to communicate this. The value of this parameter must be resolvable by the OP to an object with the data model defined below.

It is the responsibility of the OP to expose an API that allows a RP to create and manage these request configurations see below for details on the API structure.

Data Model

A verifiable credential presentation request configuration, takes the following definition

{
  "id": "<configuration-identifier>",
  "subject_identifier": "<attribute-name>",
  "generate_consistent_identifier": <true|false>,
  "proof_request": {
    "name": "Basic Proof",
    "version": "1.0",
    "requested_attributes": [
      {
        "names": ["email", "first_name", "last_name"]
        "restrictions": []
      }
    ],
    "requested_predicates": [
      {
        "name": "predicate name"
        "restrictions": [],
        "p_value": "value here",
        "p_type": "<="
      }
    ]
  }
}

This data model is inspired by that is defined and used in the Hyperledger Indy project for proof requests.

id : The identifier for the presentation configuration.
subject_identifier : See here for further details on the purpose of this field.
generate_consistent_identifier : Optional field defaulting to false. See here for more details.
proof_request : Contains the details on the presentation request, e.g which attributes are to be disclosed
- name : The name that will accompany the presentation request
- version : The version of the presentation request
- requested_attributes : Is a list of requested attributes.
  - names : Is the array containing the names of the attributes, coming from the same credential, to be disclosed.
  - restrictions : An object declaring the constraints of the attributes disclosure.
    - schema_id : Identifier of the schema the disclosed attribute must be sourced from.
    - schema_issuer_did : DID of the schema used for the disclosed credential must be issued by.
    - schema_name : Name of the schema used for the credential the attribute is being disclosed from.
    - schema_version : Version of the schema used for the credential the attribute is being disclosed from.
    - issuer_did : DID of the issuer of the credential the attribute is being disclosed from.
    - cred_def_id : Identifier of the credential definition the credential the attribute is being disclosed from.
- requested_predicates : Set of requested predicates.
  - name" : Relevant attribute name, (case insensitive and ignore spaces)
  - p_type" : The predicate type (<, >, <=, etc)
  - p_value" : The predicate value
  - restrictions" An object declaring the constraints, see above

Values in this data model can optionally include "proof variable substitutions" that will populate at the time the proof request is generated at runtime. Details can be found here

API

In order to manage the different verifiable credential presentation requests an OP can generate, the OP must expose the following endpoints.

/ver-configs HTTP POST

Request Body : Data Model Returns : id

/ver-configs HTTP GET

Returns : List of Data Model

/ver-configs/{id} HTTP GET

Returns : Data Model

/ver-configs/{id} HTTP DELETE

Return : 200 Ok Return : 404 Not Found

Verifiable Credential Presentation DIDComm Messages

The DIDComm protocol applicable to this integration is the present proof protocol

For more background into DIDComm please refer to the following links - DIDComm - DIDComm Message Anatomy - DIDComm Message Decorators

The OP when presented with a valid OIDC VC-AuthN request will generate a verifiable credential presentation request from the configuration referenced in the request.

Example Presentation Request From OP

{
    "@type": "did:sov:BzCbsNYhMrjHiqZDTUASHg;spec/present-proof/1.0/request-presentation",
    "@id": "<uuid-request>",
    "comment": "some comment",
    "~service": {
        "recipientKeys": ["8HH5gYEeNc3z7PYXmd54d4x6qAfCNrqQqEB3nS7Zfu7K"],
        "routingKeys": ["8HH5gYEeNc3z7PYXmd54d4x6qAfCNrqQqEB3nS7Zfu7K"]
        "serviceEndpoint": "https://example.com/endpoint"
    },
    "request_presentations~attach": [
        {
            "@id": "request-presentation-0",
            "mime-type": "application/json",
            "data":  {
                "base64": "<bytes for base64>"
            }
        }
    ]
}

Note - The above request should use the signed envelope format, where by the signer should be the public DID of the OP. This signed envelope should then be formatted to the defined URL format (TBA).

Example Presentation From IW

{
    "@type": "did:sov:BzCbsNYhMrjHiqZDTUASHg;spec/present-proof/1.0/presentation",
    "@id": "<uuid-presentation>",
    "comment": "some comment",
    "presentations~attach": [
        {
            "@id": "presentation-0",
            "mime-type": "application/json",
            "data": {
                "base64": "<bytes for base64>"
            }
        },
    ]
}

Note - the above response should use the encryption envelope format, using the ~service decorator from the request to prepare the encrypted content.

VC-AuthN Response

An OP, on successful authentication returns an ID token back to the RP's redirect URI. Population of this ID token is done through mapping it from the verifiable credential presentation sent by the IW back to the OP.

Verifiable Presentation -> OP ID Token

The authentication response of an OpenID Connect request features an ID token

A VC-AuthN OP uses the information disclosed by the IW in a VC Presentation to construct this ID token, the following details the different mappings to the various fields in the Id token.

Below is a list of the fields present in a standard ID token and the considerations that are made in the context of VC-AuthN.

Field	Definition	Value
iss	Issuer Identifier for the OP, must be a valid URL using the HTTPS scheme	Same as OIDC specification.
sub	Subject Identifier A locally unique and never reassigned identifier within the Issuer for the End-User	See here
aud	Audience(s) that this ID Token is intended for	Same as OIDC specification.
exp	Expiration time on or after which the ID Token MUST NOT be accepted for processing	Same as OIDC specification.
iat	Time at which the JWT was issued	Same as OIDC specification.
auth_time	Time when the End-User authentication occurred	Same as OIDC specification.
nonce	String value used to associate a Client session with an ID Token, and to mitigate replay attacks	Same as OIDC specification.
acr	Authentication Context Class Reference	Not used
amr	Authentication Methods References	Value set to vc_authn
azp	Authorized party - the party to which the ID Token was issued	Not used

Below details the additional information that will be added in the context of VC-AuthN.

pres_req_conf_id will be present as a claim in the ID token indicating the presentation request the VC-AuthN service presented to the user.

Any attributes that are disclosed in the verifiable presentation sent by the IW back to the RP will also be mapped to claims present in the ID token and added to the vc_presented_attributes object in the token.

Example

Assume in the following example Alice was given a verifiable presentation that asked for her email and first_name from any verifiable credential (i.e no restrictions were placed on the attributes disclosure). The verifiable presentation configuration was set to use email attribute disclosed as the subject identifier in the ID token mapping. Below shows an example of what the resulting ID token could look like.

{
   "iss": "https://vc.op.example.com",
   "sub": "user@example.com",
   "aud": "example_rp",
   "nonce": "n-0S6_WzA2Mj",
   "exp": 1311281970,
   "iat": 1311280970,
   "auth_time": 1311280969,
   "amr": "vc_authn",
   "vc_presented_attributes": {
      "email" : "user@example.com",
      "first_name" : "Alice"
   },
   "pres_req_conf_id": "my-conf-id"
  }

Subject Identifer Mapping.

To quote from the OpenID Connect specification on ID tokens, in particular the sub property.

sub : REQUIRED. Subject Identifier. A locally unique and never reassigned identifier within the Issuer for the End-User, which is intended to be consumed by the Client, e.g., 24400320 or AItOawmwtWwcT0k51BayewNvutrJUqsvl6qs7A4. It MUST NOT exceed 255 ASCII characters in length. The sub value is a case sensitive string

When an OP is performing VC-AuthN, and the request has reached the point where the VC presentation has been generated and sent by the IW to the OP, the OP must now map contents of this VC presentation to an OpenID ID token. The question is then raised on what should populate this field. The three options available are:

Nominate a disclosed attribute in the verifiable credential presentation that is used to populate the subject field.
Ephemeral generate an identifier for this field e.g a randomly generated GUID.
Generate a consistent identifier by hashing the immutable part of the proof-request into an encoded string

Note:

In option 2. this prevents the often desirable property of cross session correlation of an authenticated user, which will effect the ability for many integrating IAM solutions being able to conduct effective auditing.
In option 3. this method should be assessed and used with caution, as the chance of collisions for users holding credentials with exact same values is possible (e.g.: a proof-request using only first_name and last_name, would generate the same identifier for people with same first and last name).
In order to enable option 3 the presentation request configuration must have generate_consistent_identifier

UserInfo Endpoint

As defined in the OpenID Connect Spec, the purpose of this endpoint is to return claims about the authenticated end user. The RP, can use the access_token obtained during the OpenID Connect Authentication to fetch these claims. With a VC-Authn based OP, this endpoint is non-functional/implemented since the OP does not store a database of user attributes.

IAM Solution Integration

Because this specification defines extending a valid OP to include VC-AuthN support, integration with many existing IAM solutions can be added without any major additional work.

In reference to the diagram presented in section, an IAM system simply assumes the role of a RP to the VC-AuthN compatible OP. Which is identical to how many IAM solutions already federate to other supported OP's.

OP Discoverability

IANA defines a set of well-known URIs to improve discoverability on the web.

The OpenID Connect family of specifications defines how this is leveraged in their discovery specification to allow OP's to expose metadata about themselves.

Note: The mechanism of discovery for the OP via WebFinger RFC7033 is not effected via the VC-AuthN extension of OIDC, instead the only effect this integration has is adding additional metadata about the OP, details of this metadata can be found here.

The following additional metadata must be present at the OP's /.well-known/openid-configuration endpoint

The scopes_supported JSON array, should be extended to include the vc_authn scope

Auth Session Cleanup

For each authentication attempt, an auth session is created. Over Time, these can accumulate, increasing the database size. To address this issue, a configuration file specified by the environment variable CONTROLLER_SESSION_TIMEOUT_CONFIG_FILE is used to automatically clean up auth sessions based on their current state. This file contains a JSON array of different auth session states as strings.

An example configuration file would contain the following text

["expired", "failed", "abandoned"]

If no file is found no auth session cleanup is applied. If this config file is changed and the service is restarted no new clean up will be scheduled. The user must manually delete the existing Time To Live (ttl) index from the MongoDB database under the title auth_session_ttl.

The environment variable CONTROLLER_PRESENTATION_CLEANUP_TIME determined the frequency at which these sessions are deleted. It's value should contain an integer indicating the number of seconds each session will remain. By default it is set to 86400 (one day).

Un-Answered questions

SIOP instead of DIDComm for the requests between the RP and IW?
Should the verifiable credential presentation configuration data model be a valid JSON-LD object
Should the pres_req_conf_id instead be a URN so the OP does not necessarily have to host the additional configuration API?
Perhaps seperate things out so we have two specs, one for the RP <--> OP integration the other for AD <--> OP

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

README.md

README.md

Verifiable Credential Authentication via OpenID Connect

Background

Abbreviations

Component Diagram

Integration Sequence Diagram

VC-AuthN OP

Requirements

OIDC VC-AuthN Request

VC Presentation Request Configuration

Data Model

API

Verifiable Credential Presentation DIDComm Messages

VC-AuthN Response

Verifiable Presentation -> OP ID Token

Subject Identifer Mapping.

UserInfo Endpoint

IAM Solution Integration

OP Discoverability

Auth Session Cleanup

Un-Answered questions

Files

README.md

Latest commit

History

README.md

File metadata and controls

Verifiable Credential Authentication via OpenID Connect

Background

Abbreviations

Component Diagram

Integration Sequence Diagram

VC-AuthN OP

Requirements

OIDC VC-AuthN Request

VC Presentation Request Configuration

Data Model

API

Verifiable Credential Presentation DIDComm Messages

VC-AuthN Response

Verifiable Presentation -> OP ID Token

Subject Identifer Mapping.

UserInfo Endpoint

IAM Solution Integration

OP Discoverability

Auth Session Cleanup

Un-Answered questions