-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1
/
file-02.txt
502 lines (304 loc) · 99.8 KB
/
file-02.txt
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
Checking TGC_1511_Lect11_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
In this episode, we discussed zoonoses, which are diseases that can be transmitted between animals and humans. The first case presented was bovine tuberculosis (BTB), also known as consumptive disease, a chronic infection caused by Mycobacterium bovis that affects cattle, humans, and wildlife, particularly badgers in the UK. It is spread through the air, milk, and meat. While cooking meat does not destroy the bacteria, it can reduce the risk of transmission.
The second case was Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD), a fatal neurodegenerative disorder also known as "mad cow disease." First discovered in England in the mid-1990s, CJD is caused by prions, misfolded proteins that can be transmitted through consuming contaminated beef. While the risk of transmission to humans is low, it's essential to avoid consumption of undercooked meat from infected animals.
In terms of farm animal diseases, we discussed E. coli, salmonella, chigella, campylobacter, and listeria, which are found in raw milk and other raw or soft cheeses. Pregnant women are advised to avoid these products due to the risk of infection, particularly listeria bacteria acquired during pregnancy, which can lead to brain inflammation for the mother and spontaneous abortions for the baby.
We also talked about query fever (Q fever), an infectious disease caused by Coxiella burnetii, a germ neither a virus nor a bacterium. It is primarily transmitted through aerosolized dust during animal birthing and can cause pneumonia or spread to all body systems, leading to life-threatening infections.
The One Health Initiative was mentioned as a collaborative effort among environmental scientists, human physicians, and veterinarians to prevent, control, and eradicate infectious diseases and improve the health of all species. Human environmental changes can increase contact between people, domestic animals, and wildlife, leading to the emergence of new infectious diseases such as malaria, Ebola, and HIV.
Finally, we touched upon the importance of hand washing when having contact with animals, especially rubbing hands together with soap and water for at least 20 seconds, to reduce the risk of infection. In the next episode, we'll discuss ticks as vectors of disease.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect12_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
The case presented is about a family who lived in a densely wooded area and developed a rare tick-borne illness called Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever. The mother survived while her child did not, despite both being treated with antibiotics. The mother was given doxycycline, an antibiotic that works on the ribosomes responsible for protein synthesis, which is effective against rickettsiae like those causing Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever. The child was given penicillin derivative antibiotics, which are ineffective against rickettsiae.
The environment was suitable for tick-borne illness due to the presence of ticks that can carry this disease. However, neither family member recalled being bitten by a tick. Tick-borne illnesses often present with symptoms similar to other diseases, making diagnosis challenging, and early blood tests may be negative. If a doctor uses their clinical skills correctly and starts doxycycline early, most patients will recover.
Heartland virus is another tick-borne illness that was first identified in 2009 from two Missouri farmers with fever, low white blood cell count, and low platelet counts. The disease is transmitted by the Lone Star tick and has since been found in six additional cases. If a patient develops fever with low white blood cell and platelet counts without a more likely explanation and hasn't responded to doxycycline therapy, Heartland virus should be considered as a possibility.
STARI, or Southern Tick-Associated Rash Illness, is a tick-borne disease without a known cause that presents with a bullseye rash similar to Lyme disease but doesn't respond to the antibiotics used to treat Lyme. Since we haven't identified the cause of STARI, there are no tests or treatments available.
To prevent tick-borne illnesses, avoid direct contact with wildlife, use insect repellents in wooded and grassy areas, wear treated clothing, check for ticks after being in at-risk areas, and wear light-colored clothing to make ticks easier to spot. The EPA has approved a natural formula made from lemon eucalyptus oil as an alternative to DEET for insect repellent products.
In the next session, we will move on to discussing gastrointestinal illnesses.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect13_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
Today we discussed a variety of infectious diseases associated with the gastrointestinal tract. We began by discussing traveler's diarrhea, which is one of the most common illnesses for those traveling from developed to developing countries. The most common germ causing this illness is enterotoxigenic E. coli. To prevent and treat this illness, fluid replacement is crucial, as well as anti-motility agents like ammonium or peptidismol, and antibiotics under the guidance of a traveler's clinic if necessary.
We then discussed sushi, a popular food that can pose risks if precautions are not taken in its preparation. Incorrect handling and storage of fish can lead to bacterial contamination, causing foodborne illnesses. To prevent this, it is important to ensure that the fish used for sushi has been frozen to kill any parasites, and to store sushi properly to prevent bacterial growth.
We then talked about Clostridium difficile (C. diff), a gram-positive, spore-forming, anaerobic germ that can cause antibiotic-associated colitis and be life-threatening. Risk factors for this disease include antibiotic use and exposure to healthcare environments. The germ produces toxins that bind to the surface of intestinal cells, causing inflammation, formation of pus, and watery diarrhea. New treatments for this condition include fecal microbiota transplantation, which involves transplanting a healthy person's intestinal microbiota into an afflicted patient to restore a healthy state.
In our next lecture, we will discuss severe respiratory and central nervous system illnesses that can have deadly consequences.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect14_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
In this lecture, we discussed upper respiratory infections, including the common cold, sinusitis, and bronchitis. The common cold, caused by rhinovirus, is exclusively a viral illness and does not require antibiotics. Sinusitis symptoms can include facial pain or pressure, nasal congestion, and discolored postnasal drainage. However, the official recommendation from the Infectious Disease Society of America and the American Academy of Otolaryngology is initially not to treat sinus irritation with antibiotics unless there are symptoms suggesting early bacterial infection such as fever more than 101 degrees with severe pain.
Bronchitis, also exclusively a viral illness, is manifested by a clear and usually non-productive cough which sometimes keeps you awake at night unless you sit in an upright position. It will last a week to 10 days, but antibiotics are not necessary unless there are symptoms that would suggest bacterial pneumonia.
We also discussed Legionnaire's disease, caused by the bacterium Legionella pneumophila. This bacterium was responsible for an outbreak at the Bellevue Stratford Hotel in Philadelphia during a convention of the American Legion in 1976. Since then, there have been over 600 reported outbreaks worldwide. Treatment with antibiotics that are effective for intracellular bacteria is usually started when there's a suspicion of Legionnella. A retroactive diagnosis can sometimes be made by looking for a significant antibody rise in serum antibody levels over a four to six-week time interval.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect15_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
In this lecture, we discussed various infectious diseases that affect the skin and the bloodstream. We started with a brief overview of the structure and functions of the skin and the immune system's role in protecting it. Then we delved into specific skin infections, such as cellulitis, impetigo, erysipelas, and MRSA.
We also learned about sepsis, a life-threatening condition that occurs when an infection spreads throughout the body. Sepsis can be triggered by various microorganisms, including bacteria like Staphylococcus aureus and Streptococcus pyogenes. The immune system responds to these infections by producing inflammatory responses, which can lead to tissue damage and organ failure if not promptly treated.
Finally, we discussed endocarditis, an infection of the inner layer of the heart valves that is often caused by Staphylococcus aureus. This slow-progressing infection can lead to destruction of the heart valves and significant damage to heart tissue if left untreated.
In the next lecture, we will explore infections that affect the urinary tract and pelvic organs and learn more about sexually transmitted diseases (STDs).
Checking TGC_1511_Lect16_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
This lecture covered various sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) including human papillomavirus (HPV), chlamydia, gonorrhea, herpes simplex virus (HSV), and syphilis. HPV is the most common STD worldwide with over 20 million individuals in the U.S. currently infected and 6 million newly infected annually. Most HPV infections are asymptomatic but can lead to cervical cancer. There are vaccines available for HPV that protect against genotypes associated with cancer and genital warts.
Chlamydia is a common bacterial STD often asymptomatic, but if left untreated, it can cause pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) in women, which may lead to infertility. Gonorrhea, another bacterial STD, also commonly presents without symptoms, but if left untreated, it can cause PID and epididymitis in men, potentially leading to infertility.
Herpes simplex virus (HSV) is a viral infection that causes genital herpes. HSV-1 and HSV-2 can be transmitted through oral and genital sex. HSV can be asymptomatic or cause sores on the skin. Recurrences can occur throughout an individual's lifetime, but they are more common in the first five years after acquisition of the virus.
Syphilis is a bacterial infection that can lead to serious complications if left untreated. It has four stages: primary, secondary, latent, and tertiary. Tertiary syphilis can cause damage to multiple organs in the body.
The lecture also discussed testing for these STDs, with pap smears being used to screen for cervical cancer caused by HPV. There are vaccines available against certain strains of HPV that cause most cases of cervical cancer and genital warts. The vaccines work by creating antibodies that protect against chronic HPV infection. The vaccine needs to be administered before exposure to HPV infections, as there is no protection from HPV disease for infections acquired before vaccination.
The lecture ended with a discussion of ethical considerations surrounding the HPV vaccine, such as concerns about condoning premarital sex and undermining parental rights. However, national organizations are targeting girls ages 11 to 12 years old and recommend vaccination of women ages 13 to 26 to reduce HPV prevalence among men and women.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect17_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
In this lecture, we discussed infection control in hospitals, which is essential to prevent hospital-acquired infections. The four major components of the CDC program to reduce hospital infections are preventing transmission, diagnosing and treating infections effectively, using antimicrobial agents wisely, and preventing infection. Hand hygiene compliance is at best around 90%, but it's more typically in the 70 to 80th percentile, with nurses being more judicious about hand washing than physicians. Patients can protect themselves in the hospital by discouraging visits from people who are ill, asking visitors to sanitize their hands and follow hospital isolation precautions, and asking caregivers to clean their hands when entering their room. The next lecture will focus on global health issues, starting with HIV/AIDS.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect18_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
The HIV pandemic is a significant global health crisis that affects millions of people worldwide, particularly in resource-poor countries. There are several strategies for preventing HIV transmission, including male circumcision, HIV testing and counseling, use of condoms, PrEP for those at high risk, and treatment of sexual partners who test positive for HIV. PEPFAR is a U.S. program that provides support to resource-poor countries affected by the HIV pandemic. The ultimate goal for HIV prevention is the development of an effective vaccine, although this has proven challenging due to the genetic diversity and mutational capacity of the virus. Other strategies being explored are modifying host CD4 cells to make them resistant to infection.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect19_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
Tuberculosis (TB) is a bacterial disease that primarily affects the lungs, but can spread throughout the body. It is caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis and is transmitted via airborne droplets from infected individuals when they cough, speak or sneeze. The symptoms include persistent coughing, chest pain, weight loss, fever and night sweats.
A positive skin test indicates a past infection with TB, but it does not necessarily mean the individual has active TB. However, there is a risk of developing active TB in the first three years after infection or later in life due to aging or weakened immune systems. This is known as reactivation TB.
Treatment for TB involves four medications: isoniazid, rifampin, pyrazinamide, and ethambutol. The duration of treatment can range from six months to two years because mycobacteria do not divide rapidly like other bacteria. It is crucial that patients complete their full course of treatment to prevent drug-resistant strains from emerging.
Prevention efforts include a vaccine called bacillus calmette-guerin (BCG), which provides about 50% protection against active TB. The mHealth movement, using mobile devices for diagnosis and tracking, is also being used to help diagnose patients with TB and other diseases more quickly and efficiently.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect20_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
In today's lecture, we discussed the importance of traveling healthily and being prepared for potential illnesses while on vacation or traveling abroad. We looked at the CDC's Traveler's Health website as a resource for gathering information about vaccinations, diseases prevalent in different regions, and precautions to take when visiting certain areas.
We also discussed the importance of keeping track of where you have been, what kind of food and drinks you have consumed, if you have come into contact with animals or been bitten by insects, and other factors that may contribute to an illness. This information can be crucial for a doctor to make a diagnosis if you become sick after your trip.
We examined organizations like the WHO, the geosentinel surveillance network, the CDC's National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases, the International Society for Infectious Diseases, and the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service that work to monitor health issues and prevent diseases both in the US and worldwide.
Lastly, we discussed the potential role of social media in public health surveillance, particularly in reporting health risks and monitoring outbreaks. We also touched on the One Health Initiative, which is a collaborative effort among human, animal, and environmental health professionals to identify potential dangers and coordinate response efforts.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect21_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
Influenza is a viral infection of the respiratory system that can cause symptoms such as fever, coughing, sore throat, and body aches. It is most commonly spread through the air via droplets from an infected person's nose or mouth when they cough, sneeze, or talk. The virus can also be transmitted by touching contaminated surfaces and then touching the face. Most strains of influenza are seasonal and occur in the winter months due to cooler temperatures and lower humidity which favors virus survival outside of humans as well as more crowded indoor environments. The World Health Organization determines which strains of influenza will be targeted in the vaccine for the fall based on information gathering from influenza centers in 100 countries and other partners who conduct global surveillance year round. A pandemic flu is a global outbreak of a new strain of influenza that has not been previously encountered by humans and can cause severe illness and death. The last pandemic was the H1N1 swine flu in 2009. Vaccination is the best way to prevent influenza and it is recommended for all individuals over the age of six months, especially those at high risk for complications such as older adults, pregnant women, and people with chronic illnesses. Other measures to prevent influenza include washing hands frequently, covering the mouth when coughing or sneezing, avoiding contact with sick individuals, and staying home from work or school if ill. There is ongoing research into the potential of a future pandemic flu and scientists believe that it is not a matter of whether there will be another pandemic but a matter of when it will occur and what strain of the virus. Researchers are studying the genetic database of avian flu, which most closely contain proteins that resemble the 1918 Spanish flu, to advance our knowledge of how pandemics begin with the hope of designing better vaccines. However, there is ongoing debate about the potential for accidental release or misuse of these viruses and proactive plans are in place should this occur.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect22_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
Biological weapons can include viruses, bacteria, toxins, or other harmful agents used for malicious purposes. Examples of biological agents that could be used as a weapon include smallpox, anthrax, plague, tularemia, botulinum neurotoxin, and ricin. Biological weapons can be delivered through contaminated food, water, or air, making them difficult to detect. They can also have long incubation periods, which makes it even harder to identify an attack. The CDC has created a list of potential bioterrorist agents and is working on methods for early detection. Preparing for a bioterrorist attack includes having emergency kits and family disaster plans, as well as staying informed during an emergency. Rapid diagnostic testing capabilities will continue to be important tools in detecting and responding to bioterrorist attacks and controlling disease outbreaks.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect23_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
This video discusses new emerging diseases, re-emerging diseases, and diseases with unknown origins that are spreading due to human factors like technology, international travel, and trade. The viruses discussed include chikungunya, measles, mumps, whooping cough, and pertussis. Measles was declared eradicated in the U.S. in 2000 but is experiencing a resurgence due to low vaccination rates and travel-related transmission. The video also mentions that some chronic diseases, such as heart disease, may be caused by infectious agents, opening up new possibilities for treatment and diagnosis in the future.
Checking TGC_1511_Lect24_InfectiousDiseases in An Introduction to Infectious Diseases:
Infectious diseases are a global threat and can evolve rapidly. The future of infectious diseases is one of rapid changes, with diseases jumping onto planes and spreading worldwide in a matter of hours. Scientists around the world are constantly looking for signals that will help avert the next infectious disease disaster. The key to containing outbreaks will be a combination of enhanced surveillance, early detection, and rapid response.
Technology plays a crucial role in both our capacity for diagnosis and treatment and our ability to detect outbreaks before they get out of control. Enhanced surveillance can be achieved through mHealth technology like mobile apps or automated news feeds. Early detection can be accelerated by using technologies like the Google Flu Trends report, which uses key search words to predict outbreaks. Rapid response can be facilitated by accelerating the timeline for FDA approval of vaccines and treatments in a global health crisis, as was seen during the Ebola outbreak in 2014.
It is important to stay away from sick people, have an emergency kit with food, water, and supplies, and get an N95 mask that can filter small particles, bacteria, and viruses. Businesses should also have a preparedness plan in place that enables telecommuting and keeps businesses running during a pandemic.
In conclusion, it is essential to be vigilant and prepared for the ever-changing landscape of infectious diseases, as they have the potential to cause catastrophic pandemics. The good news is that with advancements in technology and global surveillance efforts, we are better equipped than ever before to detect and respond to outbreaks quickly.
Checking [01-24] How to Write about Anything in Analysis and Critique:
The first lecture of Writing Successfully introduces the course and its objectives. It focuses on the importance of reading as a foundation for good writing. Students will learn how to develop critical reading skills, understand the rhetorical strategies used in effective writing, and identify elements of successful writing such as strong arguments, use of figurative language, and word choice and order. The lecture also highlights the challenges of creating a written self-portrait and emphasizes the importance of practice and revision in developing writing skills. Exercises are provided for students to apply their understanding of these concepts in practice.
Checking [02-24] How to Be an Effective Reader in Analysis and Critique:
In this lecture we discussed the nature of texts, with examples ranging from literary works to a set of directions from one place to another. We talked about the difference between spoken and written language, and how the written word can have many lives beyond its initial creation. To read insightfully, it's important to move past our initial reactions or pre-critical response, and consider details such as point of view, tense, and voice. Understanding literary forms and genres is also essential for engaging with writing, and in the next lecture we will learn about five major types of writing: prose, poetry, drama, essay, and autobiography. We'll explore their dominant features and how understanding these can help us become better readers and writers.
Checking [03-24] How Literature Can Help in Analysis and Critique:
In this lecture, we discussed how various genres such as essay, poetry, autobiography, drama, and fiction can be employed in writing a letter to persuade an audience for a cause. While all these genres can potentially enhance the effectiveness of the letter, it's essential not to overwhelm the audience with too much information at once. The writer should use restraint, knowing when to hold back and effectively display their writerly knowledge. In this case, the goal is to get an off-leash area in a dog park. Exercises are provided for practice in combining different genres and developing one's voice to suit specific circumstances, audiences, and goals. In the next lecture, we will delve deeper into understanding and shaping voice in writing.
Checking [04-24] Shaping Your Voice in Analysis and Critique:
In this lecture, we discussed prose writing, focusing on voice in fiction. Voice refers to the unique style, tone, and personality that an author creates to convey their perspective and engage readers. Prose differs from poetry by focusing on a narrative or argument rather than a specific form or rhyme scheme. However, it can still use elements of other forms of writing for effect.
We analyzed examples from Pride and Prejudice and its parody, Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, to demonstrate how voice sets expectations for readers about the story's setting, characters, and themes. We then looked at three extreme examples of unique voices in literature: Hemingway, James, and Salinger. Hemingway uses a minimalist style that encourages careful reading, James uses subtle humor with subordinate clauses, and Salinger writes in an unfriendly or hostile voice to create interest.
Finally, we discussed the example of a conflict between neighbors over a parked car as a reminder that audience is a crucial consideration when writing. We all use different voices for various reasons, and understanding how to adapt our voice for specific purposes can have powerful effects. Writing always involves constructing an author's persona and an audience, even if it's just for oneself. In the next lecture, we will discuss engaging or constructing a reader and the dangers of not respecting one's audience.
Checking [05-24] Knowing Your Reader in Analysis and Critique:
Today, we discussed the importance of considering audience when writing. The lecture began with an analysis of two passages from a William the Conqueror history book, one written for scholars and the other for the general public. We then looked at two examples of writers who may not have respected their audiences - Edgar Allan Poe in "The Black Cat" and Charlotte Perkins Gilman in "The Yellow Wallpaper." The lecture concluded with an analysis of a student essay that demonstrated disrespect for the audience by using inappropriate tone, word choice, and style.
In terms of key takeaways:
1. When writing, you construct not only an authorial persona but also an audience. It's crucial to understand your intended audience.
2. There are different levels of audience, from specialized to general populations with varying interests in the topic.
3. Always respect your audience - avoid inconsistencies or disregarding their intelligence as seen in examples like "The Black Cat" and the student essay.
4. You can convey the same information to very different audiences, as demonstrated by the passages about William the Conqueror.
For the exercises, you will be asked to convey the same basic pieces of information to various audiences with different writing styles. In the next lecture (Lecture 6), we'll discuss effective strategies for starting an argument and analyze Jonathan Swift's "A Modest Proposal" and Henry David Thoreau's "Civil Disobedience" to develop a toolkit to help you transfer these skills to your own writing.
Checking [06-24] The Art of the Essay-How to Start in Analysis and Critique:
A successful introduction is one that uses a combination of description and explanation to make a clear specific claim about a subject while also establishing the meaning or significance of the argument. It needs to pass the "what-so-what" test, meaning we need to understand what the piece is about and why we should care. An effective opening can help keep a reader's attention over the course of an entire argument, but any delay in deferring a main claim can significantly weaken a writer's chances of persuading them to continue reading along. Next time, we'll focus on the issue of organization.
Checking [07-24] How to Organize an Argument in Analysis and Critique:
This lecture discusses the importance of effectively supporting an argument to make it persuasive to readers. It highlights three key strategies to achieve this goal: repetition, variation, and sequence/series. Repetition involves repeating important keywords or ideas throughout your writing to emphasize their significance. Variation entails presenting information in different ways to keep the reader engaged and avoid redundancy. Sequence/series focuses on organizing points in a logical and coherent manner, usually through a list format. The lecture also stresses the importance of using these strategies judiciously and not overusing them in a single piece of writing. It suggests limiting the use of sequences or series to three elements at most, and no more than one in shorter pieces, to prevent reader boredom. Finally, it advises writers to practice these strategies by defining key terms, organizing points around those terms, and repeating/varying them throughout their writing. The lecture will also ask students to practice the repetition, variation, and sequence series strategies in a paragraph or two about government and review an email they've written to persuade someone of something.
Checking [08-24] Supporting Your Argument in Analysis and Critique:
In this lecture, we looked at three key strategies for supporting an argument. First, it's essential to explain the relevance of your evidence to the conclusion you want your audience to reach. Second, make sure there's a clear connection between the evidence and the claim in question - avoid speculation, association, or correlation when presenting evidence. Third, concessions can be powerful in supporting an argument by acknowledging alternative viewpoints while also bolstering your credibility as a writer. To practice these strategies, consider writing an editorial column or letter to the editor and try incorporating a concession into your argument. In our next lecture, we'll discuss how to effectively conclude your essay.
Checking [09-24] Finishing Strong in Analysis and Critique:
In this lecture, we focused on the power of conclusions in arguments. We analyzed how different authors use their final lines to influence readers and leave a lasting impression. Henry David Thoreau's essay "Civil Disobedience" uses positive consequences to entice readers to consider his vision for less intrusive government. Jonathan Swift's satirical piece, "A Modest Proposal," employs negative consequences to persuade readers of the absurdity of his argument for using children as food. In Payne's speech on the execution of a condemned man, he uses the no viable alternatives model to convince readers that resistance to government isils. We discussed three strategies for crafting successful arguments:
1. Negative Consequences (Payne)
2. No Viable Alternatives (Swift)
3. Positive Consequences (Thoreau)
Additionally, we learned how to use conclusions to preemptively defend against attacks on character or bias due to personal stakes in the outcome. Swift's razor sharp wit and satirical edge are still readily apparent but this is also a deliberate attempt to thwart any ad hominin challenges to his writing. These would be attacks on him on his personality, so these attacks against his character or charges that his arguments are biased due to a personal stake in the outcome aren't going to work because of what he's done here at the end.
In our next three lectures, we will focus on poetry and drama and how they can help us become more engaging writers.
Checking [10-24] The Uses of Poetry in Analysis and Critique:
In this lecture, we looked at three famous poems, including "Ode on a Grecian Urn" by John Keats and
"The Red Wheelbarrow" by William Carlos Williams, to understand the concept of poetry. We learned that
poetry is language used in unusual or non-typical ways and can be difficult to define. We also looked
at the importance of voice or tone in poetry and discussed some common poetic devices like metaphor
and simile. Finally, we considered how knowing about poetry can improve your own writing by
arranging words on the page effectively, recognizing voice, and using key words and poetic
devices together.
Checking [11-24] Poetic Diction and Syntax in Analysis and Critique:
Today's lecture focused on poetry as a literary genre, discussing how understanding its conventions can help us as readers and writers. The instructor emphasized the importance of word choice and order in creating meaning, and provided examples from well-known poems to illustrate this point. In poetry, words often have multiple meanings, and the arrangement of these words on the page can create additional layers of meaning beyond the literal sense. This is a key aspect of understanding poetry, as it encourages readers to engage with the text in new ways and explore different interpretations. The lecture also discussed how poetry's origins in performance can influence its structure and use of language. In the next lecture, we will discuss drama and its connection to public speaking. Understanding the conventions of performance can help us prepare for moments when we may need to speak in public, as well as enhance our ability to read and write effectively.
Checking [12-24] Drama-Writing Out Loud in Analysis and Critique:
King Henry V's speech in Shakespeare's play "Henry V" is an example of a powerful, persuasive speech that inspires a group of soldiers to fight for their king. The speech is written in a poetic style and includes a series of rhetorical devices such as repetition, parallelism, and antithesis. Henry V uses these techniques to appeal to the soldiers' sense of honor, nobility, and desire for recognition. He also refers to them as "we" and "us," emphasizing their unity and equality with him. The speech is delivered with enthusiasm and conviction, which helps to make it memorable and effective.
When reading or writing words meant to be read aloud, presentation style and sincerity are important factors. King Henry V's speech serves as an example of a powerful, persuasive speech that inspires a group of soldiers to fight for their king, written in a poetic style with various rhetorical devices such as repetition, parallelism, and antithesis, which are used to appeal to the soldiers' sense of honor, nobility, and desire for recognition. He also refers to them as "we" and "us," emphasizing their unity and equality with him, delivered with enthusiasm and conviction, making it memorable and effective.
In today's lecture, we discuss writing that is meant to be read aloud, whether it is a speech or a story. We discuss the techniques used by Henry V in his speech as examples of rhetorical devices and how they can help make a piece of writing more persuasive and memorable. We also talk about the importance of knowing one's audience and being sincere when speaking in public or writing words that are meant to be read aloud.
In the exercises attached to today's lecture, we want you to focus on how you could write a scene with different moods such as happy, angry, bored, etc. We also encourage you to play around with your own ideas and experiences when speaking or writing words that are meant to be read aloud, as this can make your writing more personal and sincere.
In our next lecture, we will discuss autobiography, a special category of writing filled with its own unique pleasures and pitfalls.
Checking [13-24] What You Can Learn from Autobiography in Analysis and Critique:
Autobiographical writing, like the memoirs of Benjamin Franklin, should focus on three key areas: interests, abilities, and achievements (IAA). It's essential to strike a balance between individual accomplishments and a collaborative group effort when describing achievements. This can be achieved by using personal pronouns like I, we, and our in alternation. Additionally, presenting faults or failures as part of a larger process of self-development can make your writing more persuable and attractive.
Benjamin Franklin's approach to autobiography reveals the value of confining personal information to three key areas: interests, abilities, and achievements (IAA). It's essential to place individual accomplishments within a broader collective framework when describing achievements. Practice using I, we, my, our configurations of pronouns to strike a balance between self-promotion and associating yourself with groups.
Finally, try presenting your faults or failures as part of a larger process of self-development. This means casting them as indications of talent that was initially misdirected or not fully realized.
In the following lecture, we'll explore how autobiography can be used to establish oneself as a leader or authority figure, discussing Franklin and Frederick Douglass, former slave who wrote his way to a powerful position of authority.
Checking [14-24] Writing and Leadership in Analysis and Critique:
Autobiography provides insights into leadership skills through the narratives of Benjamin Franklin and Frederick Douglass. Franklin, in his autobiography, demonstrates a focus on reciprocal relations with others, showing his commitment to serving those around him while never allowing individual achievements to go unacknowledged. He also uses understatement when expressing emotions, creating intimacy without overwhelming the reader. Douglass's narrative is marked by emotional experiences, which were crucial for establishing himself as a representative leader in the reform of black-white relations, but he employs an oblique approach to avoid overwhelming readers. When developing leadership skills and presenting oneself in writing, it is essential to establish reciprocal relationships with those you serve, acknowledge individual efforts while connecting them to those you are serving, and use understatement when expressing emotions to create intimacy without alienating the reader. In our next three lectures, we will explore classical rhetoric ideas and traditions to enhance the meaning and identity in writing.
Checking [15-24] The Rules of Rhetoric in Analysis and Critique:
In this lecture, we discussed the concept of stasis, which is the lack of agreement or resolution in a debate or argument. Effective writers should identify commonplaces that are relevant to their readers and make an effort to recognize when those terms have been agreed upon and when they have not. By identifying the problematic terms and clarifying the scope and content of a debate, writers can persuade their audience more effectively. In our next two lectures, we will examine another four terms and ideas that you can incorporate into your own writing to make it more persuasive and compelling. These four terms are invention, arrangement, ethos, and pathos. In the next lecture, we'll focus on invention and arrangement.
Checking [16-24] Invention and Arrangement in Analysis and Critique:
The three concepts discussed in this lecture are kairos, invention, and arrangement. Kairos is the understanding of when it's appropriate to act or write, especially in response to a current event or trend. Invention refers to coming up with new ideas and arguments, while arrangement involves organizing those ideas in a way that makes sense and is persuasive to your audience. To be effective writers, it's important to think outside the box when it comes to these concepts. For example, my friend created her own kairos by using an analogy to connect the safety protocol violations of a subcontractor to the BP TransOcean incident, leading to the subcontractor being fired and her receiving a promotion. Additionally, writers should consider using a permission form to start their writing elsewhere other than the introduction, allowing them to fully explore their ideas without limiting themselves. In the next lecture, we'll discuss ethos and pathos, which will further enhance the persuasive power of our writing.
Checking [17-24] Ethos and Pathos in Analysis and Critique:
In this lecture, we delved into Aristotle's second mode of persuasion - pathos. Pathos refers to the ability to appeal to the emotions of an audience. We discussed how understanding and effectively utilizing pathos can significantly strengthen one's argument or writing. The lecture emphasized that pathos is most effective when combined with ethos, another mode of persuasion, which establishes credibility and authority.
We used examples from Frederick Douglass' Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave and Rose van Tynne's speech about her experiences during the Holocaust to illustrate how pathos can be employed effectively. In both cases, the speakers' personal stories elicited strong emotional responses from their audiences, thereby increasing their credibility and persuasiveness.
The lecture also provided practical examples of how pathos can be used in everyday writing, such as in a letter requesting the installation of a speed bump in a neighborhood. It was emphasized that establishing ethos is crucial to make a pathetic appeal more effective. The lecture concluded by hinting at the importance of conducting research and understanding the basics of classical rhetoric for improving one's writing skills, which will be discussed further in the next two lectures.
Checking [18-24] Finding What You Need in Analysis and Critique:
In this lecture, we discussed how to conduct effective research for a college paper on Arthurian literature. To begin with, it's important to have a clear question or thesis statement in mind to guide the research process. We also talked about the importance of having a research schedule and setting deadlines to help motivate yourself.
As you begin your research, it's crucial to approach your topic from multiple angles, looking for various perspectives and sources. This can include searching databases, reading articles and books, and even browsing shelves in libraries or bookstores. Additionally, don't forget to examine the bibliography of books and articles you find, as they may contain other helpful resources.
When selecting a topic, it's essential to strike a balance between specificity and scope. A topic that is too broad will be difficult to address in a college-level paper, while one that is too narrow may lack depth or substance. For example, a paper on the figure of King Arthur in medieval literature would likely be too broad, while an analysis of a key scene from Mallory's Mort d'Arthur might be too narrow. A more manageable topic might be the significance of the shift in Arthur's character once he founded the order of the Round Table.
Finally, it's important to have an idea of how long your research and writing process will take. Depending on factors such as familiarity with the topic and how many hours you can devote each day, a college-level research paper might take about two weeks. Keep in mind that researching and writing are necessarily interconnected tasks, but you'll eventually need to put down your books and start drafting your essay. In our next lecture, we'll discuss the process of putting all your research efforts to work as you begin writing.
Checking [19-24] Using What You Find in Analysis and Critique:
In today's lecture, we discussed how to conduct research and cite sources effectively when writing an academic paper. Here are the key points:
1. Give yourself enough time for research, rereading, and rethinking if necessary. Set deadlines to give structure to your project.
2. Develop a system for taking notes and organizing them effectively. Attributing every idea or quote to its original source is crucial.
3. When in doubt, cite. It's better to attribute a quote or idea than risk plagiarism, even if it seems unnecessary or excessive at the time.
4. In our next lecture, we will discuss strategies for getting started with writing first drafts and avoiding procrastination or fear of the task.
Checking [20-24] Getting Started-Writing First Drafts in Analysis and Critique:
Writer's block can be difficult to overcome, but there are strategies that can help. One approach is to break the writing into smaller parts and work on one section at a time. Another strategy is to write whatever comes to mind without worrying about organization or grammar first, then going back later to revise and refine. Writing in short bursts can also be helpful for some people. It's important to find what works best for you and your writing process. If all else fails, taking a break and engaging in physical activity can help spur new ideas. The goal is to get an early draft down on paper so that you have something to work with. In the next lecture, we will discuss editing that draft to make it as strong and persuasive as possible.
Checking [21-24] Editing-Finding What's Wrong in Analysis and Critique:
The lecture discusses an essay written about Charlotte Perkins Gilman's "The Yellow Wallpaper," focusing on its argumentative claim that the story is primarily concerned with gender issues rather than insanity. The instructor highlights several flaws in the paper's structure and suggests revisions to strengthen it, such as separating supporting points into their own paragraphs (e.g., the role of men, the narrator's bedroom as a prison, and the yellow wallpaper itself) and ensuring that each quote chosen supports the intended argument. The lecture concludes with the promise to revise the essay in its entirety and apply editing tools to a job letter in the next lecture.
Checking [22-24] Rewriting-Fixing What's Wrong in Analysis and Critique:
Today's lecture focused on editing and rewriting a text for clarity, coherence, and persuasion. The main idea is crucial as it should be clear, specific, and detailed, and all supporting points must be explicitly connected back to it. Assuming that the audience understands what you are trying to convey is not recommended, as your writing will need to be signposted or spelled out for clarity. Additionally, minor grammatical and mechanical mistakes can significantly impact the effectiveness of a piece of writing. In the next lecture, we will discuss ten common errors and ways to avoid them.
Checking [23-24] Avoiding Common Errors in Grammar and Usage in Analysis and Critique:
Ten common grammar and usage errors have been identified in the lecture: subject-verb agreement, misuse of there/their/there, possessive pronouns, misuse of the plural form of words ending in -o, use of to instead of would/could/should, the misuse of to be forms, overuse of passive voice, misuse of apostrophes, and confusion between your and you're. The lecture also addressed rules against splitting an infinitive and ending a sentence with a preposition but ultimately concluded that these were not worthy of being in the top ten errors.
Checking [24-24] The Power of Words in Analysis and Critique:
The lecture discusses the importance of writing and reading in our lives and provides examples of effective writing through an obituary for a bagpiper named Millen who played at D-Day. The writer creates vivid images, uses humor to engage readers, and transitions smoothly from funny moments to serious ones. This writing technique makes the obituary memorable and inspires further reading about the subject matter. The lecture encourages readers to be promiscuous in their reading and writing habits, suggesting that this approach can make one a more astute and engaged reader and writer. The lecture ends by mentioning that the courses are available for purchase online or by phone at 1-800-832-2412.
Checking 01-1 - Greece And The Western World in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In this lecture, Dr. Jeremy McInerney, Associate Professor at the University of Pennsylvania and lecturer for Ancient Greek Civilization Part 1, discusses the importance and challenges of studying ancient Greek civilization. He shares a personal anecdote about a professor who stereotyped Greeks as odd or inferior, highlighting the tendency to either idealize or dismiss them.
McInerney aims to navigate these extremes by presenting the Greeks as a culture that significantly influenced Western civilization without making them seem demigods or comic book characters. He argues that all cultures are unique, but Greek culture holds a special place for us due to historical reasons.
He encourages listeners to consider the impact of Greek culture on Western civilization and think about why it might be considered more important than others. McInerney will explore various aspects of Greek culture in the following lectures, helping us understand their accomplishments, similarities, and differences with our own culture.
Checking 01-2 - Greece And The Western World in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The speaker discusses the connections and differences between modern society and ancient Greek culture, focusing on democracy and theater. In terms of democracy, while we share the term "democracy," our systems are fundamentally different. Ancient Greeks practiced direct democracy, where all adult male citizens could participate in decision-making, whereas modern democracies have elected representatives who make decisions on behalf of the people. The concept of political parties, which are central to modern democracies, is not present in ancient Greek democracy.
Regarding theater, while the architectural form has remained similar, the content and context have significantly changed. Modern theater offers numerous performances every day, whereas ancient Athenian theater was limited to specific religious festivals. The plays performed today are adaptations or reenactments of ancient Greek works, but the experience of attending a modern play is vastly different from attending an ancient one.
In summary, while we share terms and certain aspects with the Greeks in areas like democracy (democracy) and theater, the underlying principles, practices, and experiences are significantly different in contemporary society.
Checking 01-3 - Greece And The Western World in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The speaker discusses the historical context of classical studies, focusing on the Greeks and their influence on Western culture. They highlight that while there was a rediscovery of ancient Greek culture during the Renaissance, it wasn't until the 18th and 19th centuries that a more in-depth understanding of the Greeks began to develop. This period is associated with German scholars like Johannes Winckelmann who studied artifacts from Greece, contributing to the Phil Hellenic movement, which sought to support Greece as it fought for independence from Turkey. The speaker suggests that this movement had both scholarly and political motivations, as supporting Greek culture helped solidify the idea that Greece was the root of Western European culture.
Checking 01-4 - Greece And The Western World in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The speaker discusses the influence of ancient Greece on Western society, particularly in the 19th century, when scholars and artists traveled to Greece to study its ancient culture and landscape. This period saw the creation of an idealized vision of Greece as a beautiful and perfect Eden, which could serve as a model for modern society. This idea was heavily influenced by German scholarship, with many Germans seeking to rebuild their society along Greek lines after the defeat at the Battle of Jena. However, it's important to note that ancient Greece was not inherently perfect and its inhabitants were just as human as we are today. The speaker argues that this heavy expectation placed on ancient Greece is unfair and unrealistic.
Checking 01-5 - Greece And The Western World in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In this summary, we discuss how Western cultures, particularly those in Europe and North America, have developed a strong sense of cultural superiority by looking back at their classical roots, specifically the ancient Greek civilization. This perception is often influenced by the process of alterity, where cultures see themselves as the opposite of others.
The lecture provides examples from various aspects of modern life to illustrate this connection, such as architecture (e.g., buildings in Washington D.C.'s Mall and Philadelphia's Second National Bank being designed in a neoclassical style). It also mentions literature, including Nobel Prize-winning poetry like Derek Walcott's Omeros, which draws inspiration from ancient Greek epics.
The lecture further explores how Western cultures have tied themselves to the Greeks, either closely or indirectly, in various domains, such as politics, theater, and even daily life. It ends with a somewhat controversial example: the sitcom, which is suggested as one of the questionable gifts of American culture, indicating that this connection to ancient Greece can extend even into popular entertainment.
Checking 01-6 - Greece And The Western World in Ancient Greek Civilization:
This lecture discusses the evolution of Greek culture from the Bronze Age to the end of the classical period (around 1100 BC to 300 BC), focusing particularly on the shift in comedy genre from political engagement to family-centric narratives, known as New Comedy. The lecturer emphasizes that the Greeks' cultural landscape is more diverse than commonly perceived, and this course will explore various aspects of Greek culture over the next 24 lectures.
The lecture concludes by pointing out that even iconic symbols of Greek culture, such as the Parthenon, should be considered in their historical context. Built from tribute paid to Athens, the Parthenon represents the power and influence of Athens during its empire. This suggests that seemingly familiar aspects of Greek culture might reveal different meanings when examined in their original contexts.
Checking 02-1 - Minoan Crete in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The lecture focuses on Minoan Crete, an ancient Bronze Age culture of exceptional artifacts, city planning, and aesthetic sensibility but with no surviving literature. This leads to speculation about the culture, which has fueled some fantastical theories. The lecture aims to separate fact from fiction. To understand Minoan Crete, we need to look at the development of human culture in Greece.
The earliest evidence for human culture in Greece comes from the Stone Age Frankty Cave in Argalid, where tools made from volcanic glass from Milos indicate early trade and travel across water. More complex societies can be seen in Sesklo and Dimany in Thessaly during the fifth and fourth millennia.
The culture that made a significant impact is known as Cycladic, whose evidence comes from the central Aegean islands. However, we know very little about the society that produced Cycladic figurines - marble figurines stylized to show broad shoulders and narrow hips, often with genitals depicted. These objects are aesthetically pleasing but tell us nothing without an archaeological context.
The lecture will continue by delving into the Bronze Age culture of Minoan Crete, exploring its unique features and the mysteries that surround it.
Checking 02-2 - Minoan Crete in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In the second millennium BC, around 1900-1400 BC, a significant Bronze Age culture known as Minoan culture thrived on the island of Crete. The society was characterized by a series of palaces, often referred to as palatial society, which served as administrative, religious, and economic centers. These palaces shared similar designs, featuring a central courtyard, administrative buildings, private chambers, and storage rooms or magazines.
The palace of Knossos is particularly notable, and some scholars suggest that the bottom of the throne may have belonged to a female, hinting at possible matriarchal or matrilinear society. However, this is speculative.
Minoan palaces also exhibit design similarities with ancient Near Eastern palaces, suggesting an influence from these early cultures.
Religion in Minoan society was complex, with the palaces serving as part of a religious system that included mountaintop sanctuaries, house sanctuaries, and cave sanctuaries. Goddess figurines were common in these sanctuaries. The walls of Minoan palaces often featured depictions of princes making offerings or priestesses accepting them.
In summary, the Minoan culture was a complex Bronze Age society characterized by palatial structures that served multiple purposes and were part of an intricate religious system. The influence of ancient Near Eastern cultures is evident in their architecture and social organization.
Checking 02-3 - Minoan Crete in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The speaker discusses the challenges of understanding Minoan religion due to the lack of written texts. They describe various archaeological findings, such as frescoes and artifacts, that suggest religious practices involving athletic performances and bull worship, possibly paying homage to a virile deity. The speaker also mentions the presence of goddess figurines, often depicted with snakes entwined around their arms, which could symbolize earth, regeneration, or ancestor worship but the exact meaning is unknown. They note that later Greeks referred to this earth mother as Demeter. Additionally, hilltop shrines suggest a possible sky god being worshipped. The speaker suggests a potential parallel with Near Eastern cultures, where powerful female gods often have male consorts. However, due to the lack of written texts, much about Minoan religion remains speculative and subject to interpretation.
Checking 02-4 - Minoan Crete in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The Minoan civilization, located on the island of Crete during the Bronze Age, was a highly sensitive culture that valued both natural and human beauty, as evidenced by their artwork. Their society had an earth mother figure and a virile male consort, but specific names and hymns are unknown due to the lack of written records. The Minoan palaces served as administrative, political, religious, and economic centers. They were the hub for both local trade, such as grain, wool, and oil production and distribution, and international trade, which brought in exotic goods like perfume, metals, fabrics, and precious woods from across the eastern Mediterranean. The Minoan culture is referred to as a redistributive economy, with the palaces storing resources and then dispersing them as needed. This indicates that the Cretans were in contact with many other cultures of the era, as evidenced by artifacts like Egyptian scarabs and Mesopotamian seals found in Crete. Rather than being the first Greek Bronze Age culture, it is more accurate to view Minoan civilization as the westernmost part of a broader range of Bronze Age cultures that spanned across the eastern Mediterranean during the second millennium BC.
Checking 02-5 - Minoan Crete in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The discussion revolves around the civilization and culture of Minoan Crete, specifically focusing on the island of Thera which is part of a Cretan trade and cultural network. It's unclear if Thera was a Cretan colony or an indigenous society heavily influenced by Crete. The lack of defensive walls around palaces in Crete suggests not a peace-loving culture, but one that relied on naval power for defense. The defense of Crete came from its naval strength in the eastern Mediterranean and Aegean Sea.
Sir Arthur Evans, a journalist, played a significant role in the archaeology of Minoan Crete. He discovered and excavated the site of Knossos, providing much of our knowledge about Minoan Crete. Evans' work is an example of 19th and early 20th century archaeology, similar to Heinrich Schliemann at Troy and Mycenae, and Leonard Woolley at Nineveh.
In essence, the lecture highlights the interconnectedness of civilizations in the eastern Mediterranean and Aegean during the Bronze Age, particularly focusing on Minoan Crete, Thera, and their extensive trade networks. It also emphasizes the importance of individual archaeologists like Evans in shaping our understanding of ancient cultures based on their discoveries and interpretations.
Checking 02-6 - Minoan Crete in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The speaker is discussing archaeologist Sir Arthur Evans, who excavated the Minoan ruins at Knossos, Crete, despite not being a professional scholar or university professor. He was passionate about uncovering the real objects that could attest to the reality of classical Greek culture, which was often only known through myths and later historians. Evans' work is significant because without him and other early archaeologists, the study of the Bronze Age would not exist. However, there are criticisms of these early archaeologists, such as Evans, for their methods of excavation and record-keeping.
The speaker also raises the question of how reliable a historian's interpretation can be when studying a past civilization with no literary records, such as the Minoan civilization. The speaker notes that much of what is seen at Knossos today may be more Evans' reconstruction than original Bronze Age artifacts. While some archaeologists argue that one should only rely on the archaeology itself, the lack of literary sources for the Minoan world forces historians to rely heavily on interpretation and the work of influential figures like Evans. The speaker concludes by praising Evans for his contributions to our understanding of the Minoan civilization but notes that his work also held back the study of the Bronze Age by positing a relationship between Minoan Crete and the Mycenaean world on the mainland, which will be discussed in the next lecture.
Checking 03-1 - Schliemann And Mycenae in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In the lecture, we discussed Heinrich Schleeman, the archaeologist who uncovered the Mycenaean culture of mainland Greece. Similar to Sir Arthur Evans with Minoan Crete, Schleeman was not a professional scholar but a businessman who made a fortune on the California gold fields. His love for the world of Homer led him to excavate at Mycenae in 1876, where he discovered traces of a wealthy Bronze Age culture that he believed to be the homeland of Homer's Mycenaean Greeks, the Achaeans.
Schleeman's work has been criticized for its dramatic storytelling and potential fabrications, as his findings were often sensationalized to excite audiences. However, subsequent research has shown that the civilization he uncovered was approximately 300-400 years older than the Trojan War, which Schleeman initially thought he was excavating. The grave goods found in Mycenae's shaft graves are incredibly rich, earning it the label "Mycenae rich in gold."
The question arises as to where this material wealth came from, as Greece is not naturally rich in gold. This has led scholars to investigate trade connections and resources that the Mycenaean civilization may have had access to during their peak around 1600 BC. In summary, Schleeman played a significant role in making archaeology and Greek culture internationally famous, but his findings require careful examination and subsequent research for a more accurate understanding of the Bronze Age civilizations of Greece.
Checking 03-2 - Schliemann And Mycenae in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The Mycenaean Greeks are believed to have originated from Anatolia (modern-day Turkey) around 1900 BC, as suggested by the sudden appearance of Anatolian pottery in Greece and linguistic traces of an earlier non-Indo-European language. However, the period between their arrival in Greece and the rise of Mycenaean power around 1600-1500 BC is not well documented. By this time, the people at Mycenae were burying their chieftains with elaborate burial offerings, indicating an elite culture dominated by an aristocracy. The Mycenaean civilization was characterized by strong fortifications, warrior culture, and martial artifacts, as seen in Cyclopean walls, sword blades depicting battles, and graves marked with chariots. This suggests that the Mycenaeans were a powerful and militaristic society within the broader Bronze Age or Ecumene during the second millennium BC.
Checking 03-3 - Schliemann And Mycenae in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The Mycenaean culture, discovered in excavations led by Schliemann in the late 19th century, was characterized by luxury and wealth, as evidenced by fine gold work, alabaster vessels, and other artifacts. In the following centuries, further excavations revealed that Mycenae functioned like a Minoan palace, with craftsmen and workers living below the royal complex. The culture also borrowed heavily from the Minoan civilization in terms of motifs and styles.
The debate surrounding the relationship between the two cultures revolved around whether Crete colonized the mainland or if Mycenae was an independent culture influenced by Cretan artwork due to trading contacts. This debate was largely resolved in the 1950s with the translation of Linea B, a writing system used in Mycenae, which was shown to be Greek, indicating that the Mycenaean culture was indigenous and not a direct offshoot of Cretan culture.
Checking 03-4 - Schliemann And Mycenae in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In summary, around 1450 BC, Knossos, a palace in Crete, was inhabited again for about 75 years by people who kept records in Linear B script, suggesting that the final phase of Knossos was occupied by Mycenaean Greeks. This discovery implied that Mycenaean culture had grown under Cretan influence but eventually became dominant, overthrowing the Minoan culture of Crete around 1450 BC. The Aegean and wider eastern Mediterranean were initially under a Cretan sphere of influence, but between 1600 and 1400 BC, there was a dramatic shift in control to a Mycenaean one. Additionally, the story of Greek hero Thesias and his slaying of the Minotaur, a creature that symbolized Cretan power, is cited as further evidence supporting this shift in power.
Checking 03-5 - Schliemann And Mycenae in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The speaker proposes that the myth of Theseus and the labyrinth might be based on a historical event: a revolt against Minoan rule in Crete around 1450 BCE, followed by a Mycenaean invasion. They argue that the story has been passed down as a "folk memory" of this period, with the structure of the labyrinth representing the palace at Knossos and the fleets of Minoan ships symbolizing their power. The speaker suggests that while our knowledge of the Bronze Age is largely based on archaeological evidence, which requires careful interpretation, we actually know more about it than the ancient Greeks did because they lacked a historical sense until the 5th century BCE and had little reliable information about their past. They conclude that despite our attempts to reconstruct history, the Greeks' lack of a clear understanding of their past allowed them to use it as a source for imagination and creativity in their myths and stories.
Checking 03-6 - Schliemann And Mycenae in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The speaker discusses how ancient Greek poets, such as Homer and Hesiod, approached the past in a way that can be described as mythopoetic. Rather than focusing on historical accuracy, they crafted stories based on vague memories of the Bronze Age, creating a heroic past that became essential to Greek identity. This poetic distillation of oral tradition, as seen in works like the Iliad and Odyssey, was more important to Greeks than an accurate understanding of their historical past. The speaker suggests that this mythopoetic approach allowed the Greeks to create a distinct cultural identity that endured through subsequent generations. In future lectures, the speaker plans to discuss the collapse of the Bronze Age culture and the role of Homer and the Dark Ages in shaping Greek identity and culture.
Checking 04-1 - The Long Twilight in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The lecture focuses on the end of the Bronze Age in Ancient Greece and the subsequent shift to Iron Age cultures. A significant catastrophe marked the end of Bronze Age culture, but the exact cause and nature of this event remain debated. One popular theory suggests that it was due to a massive volcanic eruption on the island of Thera (Santorini), which may have also affected Cretan culture. The discovery of Thera during the construction of the Suez Canal supports this theory, as it uncovered a Bronze Age town buried under layers of volcanic ash and stone. Another Greek excavator pointed to evidence on Crete itself, such as displaced stones at Tillisos, suggesting a tidal wave caused by the eruption may have affected the island. However, this theory remains one of many debated explanations for the end of the Bronze Age in Greece. The lecture also touches upon the role of epic poetry in shaping Greek perceptions and memories of their past, leading to the creation of a Golden Age rather than a Bronze Age.
Checking 04-2 - The Long Twilight in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The collapse of Minoan civilization on Crete did not occur due to the volcanic eruption at Thera, despite the similarities between the two events in Greek mythology and archaeological evidence. The scientific understanding of the Thera eruption's date (around 1600 BC) contradicts the timeline of the decline of Minoan civilization, which was still thriving around that time. Additionally, marine style pottery found on Crete but not on Thera supports this argument, as it suggests that Thera had already been destroyed before the creation of this type of pottery. Lastly, recent archaeological evidence from sites in North Eastern Crete indicates that people lived long enough after the Thera eruption to clean up and rebuild their homes, suggesting that they were not completely devastated by the event. Therefore, while the Thera eruption is a romantic story, it is not considered the primary explanation for the collapse of Minoan power on Crete.
Checking 04-3 - The Long Twilight in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The speaker suggests that the Minoan civilization weakened over time due to a gradual shift of power from Minoans to Mycenaeans, rather than a sudden collapse. This shift may have occurred through conflicts in the trading areas between the two cultures, with evidence found in frescoes and wall paintings depicting naval expeditions and soldiers disembarking. The balance of power shifted towards the Mycenaeans, resulting in Minoan Crete becoming less able to control trade in the Eastern Mediterranean and eventually being subject to invasion from the mainland.
The speaker then discusses the collapse of Mycenaean power around 1200 BC. A popular theory at the time was that the Mycenaeans were defeated by the Dorians, a group of Greeks from the north, who invaded and physically overwhelmed their cousins in the south. Evidence supporting this theory includes the distribution of Greek dialects and a Greek myth known as the story of the return of the Heraclidae. The speaker concludes by questioning what happened to the Mycenaeans and suggesting that understanding the collapse of their power is an interesting topic for further study.
Checking 04-4 - The Long Twilight in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The argument presented suggests that the Dorian invasion may not be the correct explanation for the decline of the Mycenaean world. Here are the reasons given against the Dorian invasion theory:
1. Linguistic evidence is unreliable as a guide to population movements, especially considering the distribution of Greek dialects.
2. It is challenging to explain the presence of Dorians for several hundred years as Greek speakers while simultaneously being outside the Mycenaean world.
3. Historically, there is no material evidence for a distinct Dorian culture or pottery style that can be tied to the period before the alleged invasion.
4. The idea of the Sons of Heracles returning to the Peloponnes isn't directly related to the Dorians, as claimed descent from Heracles and being Dorian were considered separate claims.
5. A newer theory posits that the Dorians were already present in the Mycenaean world, serving as workers and farmers, rather than invaders from outside Greece. This theory suggests an internal upheaval or systems collapse, which could explain the apparent decline of the Mycenaean world.
6. The Trojan War is proposed as evidence for this internal upheaval theory. If there was a historical truth to the Trojan War, it might suggest that the Mycenaean princes faced a massive campaign and their Dorian slaves or serfs rose up to overthrow them. This theory suggests that the Dorian invasion may not have been an external event but rather an internal conflict within Mycenaean Greece.
In summary, the argument presents evidence suggesting that the Dorian invasion might not have occurred as a separate event from the Mycenaean world but could be linked to internal upheavals and conflicts, such as the Trojan War.
Checking 04-5 - The Long Twilight in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The site identified as Troy, excavated by Schlieman, is strategically important due to its control over sea-borne trade between the Black Sea and the Achaean, as it's located at the Dardanelles where the current flows outward, making it difficult for ships to sail upstream without a wind behind them.
At this site, archaeological findings reveal layers of Bronze Age civilizations, with Troy 6, 7a, and 7b corresponding to the end of the Bronze Age. These levels feature fortified walls, towers, and a likely King's Palace or Megaron. There is suggestive evidence of a destruction level at these periods, though it's not definitively clear whether this was caused by warfare or other factors like earthquakes.
The historical kernel of the Trojan War, as depicted in Homer's myth, may be rooted in a real Mycenaean Greek campaign against Troy late in the Bronze Age. However, whether they were actually successful or built a Trojan horse is uncertain. Additionally, there was another cycle of epic poems called the Nostoi (Returns), which focused on the hardships faced by the heroes upon their return from Troy, such as Ajax committing suicide and Odysseus's struggles to return home.
Checking 04-6 - The Long Twilight in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The speaker is discussing the traditionally disastrous returns from Troy in Greek mythology and how it impacted the Mycenaean world. They suggest that instead of a single Dorian invasion, there was a Dorian explosion that weakened and eventually overpowered Mycenae. The collapse of the Bronze Age wasn't limited to Greece but occurred around the entire Eastern Mediterranean during the 12th and 11th centuries BC.
The Sea Peoples, mentioned in Egyptian records, include names like Shadana, Tirsenae, Eqwesh, and Danyen, which have been linked to the Achaeans and Danaans in Greek history. This suggests that Mycenaean Greeks may have left Greece and settled elsewhere, contributing to the collapse of Bronze Age civilization while also suffering its effects.
Two pieces of evidence supporting this theory are:
1) The Arcadocypriot dialect spoken on Cyprus, which shares similarities with central Peloponnesian Greek, could indicate that people from the Peloponnes sailed to Cyprus.
2) Among the Sea Peoples were the Pelliset, who are also known as Philistines and inhabited Palestine. The type of pottery found in the earliest layers of Philistine cities is Mycenaean, suggesting that some Philistines could have been Mycenaean Greeks who never returned from Troy.
The speaker concludes by speculating that Goliath of Gath might have been a descendant of Agamemnon, tying together the idea of a Trojan War and its potential impact on Greek history.
Checking 05-1 - The Age Of Heroes in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In Lecture 5 of the series on Greek civilization, the focus shifted from the Bronze Age to the period known as The Age of Heroes. The lecture discussed the decline and collapse of Bronze Age cultures in Greece, particularly Minoan Crete and Mycenaean Greece, around 1200 BC. This decline is evident archaeologically, with a significant decrease in the number and size of settlements over the centuries following the 12th century.
The reasons for this decline are not definitively known, but possible explanations include migration to safer highland areas due to social unrest, such as marauders or pirates, or a breakdown of social order. An example given was the site of Lavranda in Crete, where occupation ended during the Bronze Age, and later excavations revealed late Minoan pottery on a hilltop site nearby, suggesting that people had fled to safer locations.
The lecture also noted that many fortresses once occupied by Mycenaeans were abandoned or taken over by squatters after 1200 BC, indicating a lack of central authority and a decrease in quality of life. Some demographers suggest that such a drastic decline in population would have been unsustainable if it continued at the same rate, potentially leading to the extinction of these societies.
In summary, Lecture 5 discussed the decline and collapse of Bronze Age cultures in Greece around 1200 BC and suggested possible reasons for this phenomenon, including migration due to social unrest and the breakdown of social order. The lecture also noted that such a significant decline in population could have led to the extinction of these societies if it continued at the same rate.
Checking 05-2 - The Age Of Heroes in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The interpretation suggests that during times of crisis or breakdown in central authority, such as when the Mycenaean sites' inhabitants could no longer pay bills or secure food supplies, they might have abandoned their urban lives and become itinerant herders. This lifestyle, characterized by mobility and temporary shelters, leaves little archaeological trace, making it difficult for historians to track these people later on.
Following the decline of the Mycenaean culture, a new society known as the Oikos emerged during the Dark Ages (around 1100 - 800 BC). This society was centered around a chieftain's household and was much simpler than the complex social life of the Bronze Age. The chieftains, called Basileis, still ruled over smaller domains but their lifestyle was markedly different from that of the Mycenaean kings.
The Oikos was a long hut where the chieftain, family members, retainers, serfs, and slaves lived. The level of sophistication during this period was not as high as the Bronze Age, but there has been evidence to suggest that the recovery after the Mycenaeans was faster than previously believed. Three places in particular have made archaeologists reconsider the Sub-Mycenaean period at Lefkhandi on the island of Eubia. The monumental building found there suggests that people from Eubia were trading outside of Greece as early as 950 BC, hinting at a more vibrant and recovered society than previously thought during the Dark Ages.
Checking 05-3 - The Age Of Heroes in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In this information, we have a discussion about the Mycenaean world and its subsequent periods, focusing on areas outside the traditional heartland of the Mycenaean citadels. The places mentioned are Lethcandy in Greece, Eletia, and Calipothi sanctuary, all showing signs of continuity from the Bronze Age to the Iron Age.
At Lethcandy, archaeologists found a burial that appears to be a heroic one, with cremated remains of a man, a woman, and four horses, suggesting a powerful chieftain or leader. Similar findings were made in Eletia, where dozens of tombs from the sub-Mycenaean period (10th century) have been excavated, showing signs of trade not only locally but also outside Greece. Calipothi sanctuary, near Eletia, has evidence of continuous use dating back to Mycenaean times.
The speaker suggests that the areas mentioned are peripheral to the center of the Mycenaean world and that the end of the Bronze Age may not have been as catastrophic in these regions as previously thought. Instead, there might be a less overwhelming collapse and continuity from the Bronze Age into the Dark Ages and Iron Age.
Continuity is challenging to establish since it requires demonstrating practices, habits, or styles found both in the Bronze Age and carried through into the Iron Age. However, language and religion can provide examples of continuity despite significant differences between the two periods. For instance, while the writing systems were different, the Greeks spoke Greek from Mycenaean times to the classical period. Similarly, gods such as Athena and Poseidon are found in both Mycenaean records and later Greek mythology.
In summary, the information presents a picture of areas outside the traditional Mycenaean heartland showing signs of continuity from the Bronze Age into the Iron Age, suggesting that the end of the Bronze Age may not have been as catastrophic in these regions as previously thought. The search for concrete evidence of continuity remains a challenge for archaeologists.
Checking 05-4 - The Age Of Heroes in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The question of religious continuity from the Bronze Age into the classical period is complex. While there are elements of continuity, such as sacred sites like Piges Cophysus, the religious systems and deities associated with those sites changed significantly over time. For example, the temple of the river god Cophysus was replaced by an early Christian church, with stones from the pagan temple reused in the construction of the church. This illustrates a sacred site maintaining its status as a holy spot but with a completely different religious system.
Similarly, Mycenaean sites often had later classical towns built on top of them, but their functions and purposes evolved over time. For instance, what was once a Mycenaean palace might become a temple in the classical period. The relationship between Bronze Age and later Greek cultures is complex, with many differences emerging in the 8th century and beyond.
One significant change during this period was the writing down of epic poetry, which marked a monumental shift from oral traditions. Previously, oral poets had been telling heroic stories that varied from performance to performance. With the advent of written literature, these stories became more standardized and fixed. In the next few lectures, we will explore other aspects of the archaic revolution in Greece, including changes in trade, politics, and cultural centers like Delphi and Olympia.
Checking 05-5 - The Age Of Heroes in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The shift from oral to written poetry, as exemplified by the Homeric poems like the Iliad and Odyssey, around 725 BCE, was a significant cultural event in Ancient Greece. The written form solidified these epic poems into what could be considered a sacred text among the Greeks, serving as a moral guide for their behavior.
The Homeric heroes, presented as twice the size of normal men in terms of strength and valor, established a code of honor based on shame rather than guilt. This code emphasized performance and served as a model for Greek men to emulate. The poems also provided a vivid portrayal of heroism, with military and athletic valor being the main focus.
However, it's important to note that these poems are not just instruction manuals; they offer more than just prescriptions for behavior. To illustrate this, the speaker refers to two contrasting episodes: one showcasing the performance of valor (Saupedon and Glaucus) and another depicting a moment of intimate interaction between Achilles and Priam (which will be discussed in another lecture).
In summary, the Homeric poems, as they transitioned from oral to written tradition, became significant cultural artifacts in Ancient Greece. They served as moral texts that Greeks returned to time and time again, establishing a code of honor based on heroic performance and shame, while also providing vivid portrayals of heroism that Greek men would model themselves upon.
Checking 05-6 - The Age Of Heroes in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The speaker discusses the cultural unity among the ancient Greeks, as represented in Homer's epics, particularly the Iliad. They argue that the Trojans, rather than the Achaeans or Greeks, represent family and community, with Hector being a significant hero. Despite knowing his fate, Hector remains steadfast in his duty to Troy, embodying a Homeric sentiment of honor and sacrifice.
As Greek culture was developing during this period, households were growing into villages and eventually towns, marking the emergence of the city-state or polis. However, unlike other ancient civilizations, the Greeks never coalesced to form a nation, instead asserting their independence and autonomy in separate city-states.
The speaker suggests that Epic became a powerful statement of Greek values, serving as the core of Greek identity. Being Greek meant being similar to other Greeks but remaining distinct from them, creating a paradox at the heart of Greek history.
Checking 06-04 - Pleasure And The Right Life in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The passage discusses the role of pleasure in identifying virtues as defined by Aristotle. Virtue, according to Aristotle, is a habit of choosing the mean between extremes in actions or emotions. The presence of pleasure indicates the formation of a habit, and when pleasure is associated with choosing rightly about an activity, it can be an indicator of virtue.
The author uses examples such as food and drink, driving, and music to illustrate their points. In each case, finding pleasure not just in the thing itself but in using it correctly to enhance the overall experience indicates the presence of some degree of virtue. The author also emphasizes the importance of habituation and deliberation in the development of moral virtue.
To acquire a taste for the right things, such as music or food, one must be exposed to different kinds of these activities and develop an appreciation for them over time. This process involves exposure, deliberation, consideration of alternatives, and reflection on consequences. The goal is to become habituated to take pleasure in the right things and make the right choices.
Checking 06-05 - Pleasure And The Right Life in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The text discusses the importance of exposure to various experiences and pleasures in human moral maturation, as emphasized by Aristotle. These experiences can help one acquire tastes for activities like travel, music, or service, which can deepen virtues. This concept is illustrated using examples from literature, such as Jane Austen's novels that highlight the cultivation of virtues within families. The text also mentions Dante's Divine Comedy, where the protagonist experiences the punishments in hell and therapies in purgatory, reflecting an Aristotelian emphasis on gaining experiences to understand pleasure's role. In contrast, some modern theories of ethics might not prioritize these experiences as much.
Checking 06-06 - Pleasure And The Right Life in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The passage discusses Dante's portrayal of sin and punishment in his work "The Divine Comedy." Lust is depicted as a less severe sin than others, with the souls punished for it being like flighty birds constantly blown around in a maelstrom. This, according to the speaker, reflects Dante's personal experience with disordered love. In Purgatory, lust is again less severe and fire is introduced, symbolizing purification to order loves appropriately.
The speaker then compares this perspective to modern novels like Aldous Huxley's "Brave New World." While Huxley's work advocates for a utilitarian, hedonist society, it ultimately results in the elimination of freedom and self-sacrifice. The speaker suggests that even though Huxley disagrees with Aristotle's view on virtue and community, his novel shows the importance of habituation in pleasures, acknowledging Aristotle's point about the need for habituation to order loves correctly.
The speaker concludes by stating that they will discuss the topic of ordering one's loves and the place of pleasure in the next lecture, focusing on Book 10 of Aristotle's "Nicomachean Ethics."
Checking 06-07 - Attaining True Happiness in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In this final lecture on Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, the focus is on Book 10 and its treatment of happiness as the goal of human life. Aristotle reiterates his initial thesis that human life is designed for happiness and not personal amusement. He defines happiness as a life of real activity and virtue, emphasizing the development of virtuous patterns of thinking, feeling, and choosing, all done in moderation and with rationality at the center.
Material conditions like health, wealth, reputation, and a good background city are necessary for a happy life but do not constitute happiness themselves; instead, what is needed is an excellence of character, or the development of virtues. Aristotle highlights the communitarian dimension of genuine happiness by emphasizing the need for friends and the integration of individual and family considerations within the right kind of political community, as further discussed in his book The Politics.
The Nicomachean Ethics has been influential in Western thinking about personal happiness and morality, while its emphasis on the role of a political community in achieving genuine happiness sets the stage for further discussions in The Politics.
Checking 06-08 - Attaining True Happiness in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In Book 10 of Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle introduces a new claim that happiness will best consist in the contemplative life and that the contemplative life is superior to the active life. This might come as a surprise given his respect for political figures in previous books. However, he sees both lives as having possibilities for happiness but privileges the contemplative life due to its association with human rationality used practically and politically. He acknowledges the importance of the active life in providing material conditions, social stability, reputation, friendship, economy, and political participation. Yet, he argues that the contemplative life is superior because it offers an even better way of finding happiness.
This argument can be attributed to Aristotle's response to his intellectual forebears, such as Plato, and a sense of appreciation for the scholarly leisure he enjoyed in his own life. By understanding this context, readers can appreciate the nuanced view that Aristotle presents on the role of happiness in both active and contemplative lives.
Checking 06-09 - Attaining True Happiness in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The text discusses the philosophical views of Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle regarding the contemplative life as a path to happiness. This intellectual lifestyle was a privilege that few could afford due to the need for leisure, but it was highly valued by these thinkers. The contemplation of objects, in this case, the highest possible object (God), is considered superior to other practical pursuits such as politics or poetry. Aristotle suggests different arguments for the existence of God, one being in his book Physics where he argues that the universe needs an unmoved mover to explain its motion, and another more abstract argument in Metaphysics where he envisions God as a being so noble that it would only focus on itself, not actively intervening in history as depicted in Jewish, Christian, or Muslim traditions.
Checking 06-1 - From Sicily To Syria in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In this lecture, we delve into the period of ancient Greek civilization around the 8th century, focusing on the growth of trade and colonization. The Greeks began to write down their epic poems for the first time during this era, which had a significant impact on their moral code and education system. The rise of Poles (city-states) also marked a shift from smaller communities towards larger ones.
This lecture primarily focuses on the emergence of trade and colonization, with Greeks establishing cities all over the Aegean, Black Sea, and Western Mediterranean. Unlike later colonial experiences, these were not aimed at annexing territory or exploiting native populations. Instead, it was a result of the Greeks exporting their people, who settled in places like Massilia (Marseille), Emporio (Spain), Cyrene (North Africa), and Olbia (Ukraine).
The lecture concludes with a reminder that this colonial experience in ancient times was vastly different from the colonization of the 19th century, as it was not driven by large nation-states or capitalistic economic interests. Instead, it was a movement of people seeking wealth and opportunities elsewhere.
Checking 06-10 - Attaining True Happiness in Ancient Greek Civilization:
Aristotle's conception of God in the Nicomachean Ethics is as a perfect sphere, a pure mind that contemplates itself and serves as the source of attraction for the rest of the universe. He views contemplation as the ultimate source of happiness and recognizes that not everyone can engage in this activity due to societal roles. Aristotle's ethics aim to address the universal questions about how life should be lived, with happiness as the final end. He believes that every generation and culture must consider these questions, and he emphasizes personal decision-making regarding one's own happiness. Aristotle posits that happiness is living a virtuous life, although material necessities are necessary for this to be possible. The ethics presented by Aristotle have had a lasting impact on various forms of theology and continue to influence modern thought.
Checking 06-11 - Attaining True Happiness in Ancient Greek Civilization:
This passage discusses the ethical philosophy of Aristotle, focusing on his concept of virtue as habits of choice that allow individuals to take responsibility for their actions and their consequences. Aristotle's ethics emphasizes personal development and the cultivation of virtues, such as temperance, justice, prudence, and courage, which help individuals make wise decisions and find ease in doing responsible actions.
The passage highlights that while habits play a crucial role in shaping our behavior, they do not diminish individual responsibility. Instead, habits can provide a second nature that makes it easier to choose wisely and act responsibly. The author suggests that Aristotle's ethics remains relevant today, particularly in the works of philosophers like Alasdair MacIntyre and Martha Nussbaum, who have adapted Aristotle's ideas to contemporary society and cultures.
In summary, this passage discusses Aristotle's philosophy of virtue ethics, which emphasizes personal responsibility, habit formation, and the cultivation of virtues for wise decision-making in a world where actions have consequences. The author suggests that Aristotle's ideas continue to be relevant and inspiring to modern philosophers.
Checking 06-12 - Attaining True Happiness in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The text discusses the relevance of Aristotle's ethics, particularly his focus on virtue rather than law, for contemporary American culture. It highlights that while Americans generally prefer minimal regulation and view laws as restraints for criminals, there are instances where regulation is necessary to ensure appropriate empowerment or distribution.
The text introduces the concept of natural law theory, which originates from Aristotle's insights about natural justice in Book 5 of his ethics. This theory emphasizes the importance of an internal dimension alongside external regulations, and proposes that a sense of natural law within us can lead to personal growth and happiness if we cooperate with it.
Natural law theory also draws upon Aristotle's balanced notion of pleasure as a guide for moral decisions. It suggests that our natural pleasures point towards what human beings are designed to do, and where there will be happiness if we develop them in a mature, complete, and well-balanced manner.
The text concludes by encouraging the reader to explore more about Aristotle's legacy through Great Courses available at www.teach12.com or by calling 1-800-TEACH-12.
Checking 06-2 - From Sicily To Syria in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The Greeks sent out colonists to various parts of the Mediterranean due to a lack of fertile land in Greece, leading to overpopulation and pressure on resources. Greek colonies were typically located near rich, well-watered soil for agricultural purposes. Additionally, younger sons often joined these expeditions as a means of securing land, similar to how younger sons of the British Empire might join the church or the Indian army during the Raj. This practice was carried down through generations. An example of this mentality can be found in the Odyssey, where Odysseus is appalled at the prospect of unused, fertile land belonging to the lawless Cyclops. The Greeks saw this land as ripe for colonization and were disappointed that there were no craftsmen to build ships to exploit it.
Checking 06-3 - From Sicily To Syria in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In the 8th century, as smaller communities were growing into larger city-states, or polis, there was a shift from simple household authority to the need for institutions of justice. This led to constant conflict, a condition known as stasis, in the Greek city-states. Colonization served as a safety valve, allowing cities to send troubled populations to establish new colonies and alleviate internal conflicts. These colonies often consisted of people from different parts of the Greek world who united under a common identity, such as the Syracusans or Tarantines. The need for land, the emergence of city-states, and the desire to escape stasis contributed to the Greeks' propensity for colonization in the Mediterranean.
Checking 06-4 - From Sicily To Syria in Ancient Greek Civilization:
In this passage, the focus is on the influence of trade and colonization on ancient Greek civilization during the 8th and 7th centuries, particularly in relation to their contact with the Phoenicians. The Greeks' engagement with other cultures led to significant cultural exchange, most notably in the form of the alphabet.
The author highlights that writing, which had disappeared at the end of the Bronze Age among the Greeks, reappeared around 725 BCE. However, instead of Linear B, they adopted an alphabet that originated from a Northwest Semitic language, likely used by the Phoenicians or their ancestors.
The passage also suggests that trade and colonization facilitated Greek exploration and settlement across the Mediterranean world. This intermingling of cultures is believed to have had a profound impact on Greek society during this period. The author mentions specific instances such as Pythakousai in the Bay of Naples, where both Greeks and Phoenicians coexisted and traded.
In summary, this passage emphasizes that trade and colonization played a crucial role in introducing the Greeks to new cultures, most notably the Phoenicians, and resulting in significant cultural exchange, such as the adoption of the alphabet.
Checking 06-5 - From Sicily To Syria in Ancient Greek Civilization:
The Greeks, around the end of the 8th century, adopted a Semitic writing system to write their language, which they made purely phonetic. They took words like "aleph" (ox) and "bet" (house) from this system and used them as the letters alpha (ah) and beta (but), respectively. This marked a significant shift in the world of writing, as it reduced the number of symbols needed to write down Greek, making it easier compared to other systems with hundreds or thousands of ideograms. The first known Greek writings are Homer's poems, suggesting cultural influence from their trading and colonizing contacts, particularly with the Phoenicians. These early coherent Greek texts were found not in Greece, but in Pithecusa (near Naples) and Almena, locations where Greeks were living next to Phoenicians. The theory suggests that bilingual children from these populations may have contributed to the creation of the Greek alphabet.
In addition to adopting a new writing system, the Greeks also gained intellectual, spiritual, and cultural insights from their interactions with the wider world, as illustrated by the poet Hesiod's works, which describe the origins of Greek gods. These poems introduce stories like that of Uranos being attacked by his son Kronos and Kronos being deceived by Zeus, reflecting themes of physical attack and deception between generations of gods. This suggests a blending of ideas from different cultures as the Greeks incorporated elements into their own mythology and understanding of their gods.
Checking 06-6 - From Sicily To Syria in Ancient Greek Civilization:
This analysis discusses the significant influence of ancient Near Eastern culture on Greek culture during the 8th century BCE, which is often referred to as an "orientalizing period." The speaker argues that Greek poetry, such as Hesiod's Theogony, shows strong similarities with ancient Near Eastern texts like The Epic of Kumabi and the Babylonian creation epic, Anuma Elish. This influence can also be seen in the material arts of the time, with Syrian bowls being exported to Greece.
The speaker emphasizes this connection because there have been allegations that classicists and ancient historians have systematically ignored or downplayed the Afro-Asian roots of classical culture. However, they contend that for at least the last 30 to 50 years, the most productive line of inquiry in Greek history has been exploring the deep debt Greeks owed to the ancient Near East, particularly during the Bronze Age and Iron Age.
In conclusion, the speaker suggests that Greece was not a unique, self-sufficient cradle of Western civilization but was instead intimately connected to and influenced by the broader Eastern Mediterranean throughout its history.