Skip to content

Are machines "learning" anything? This repository explores some of the concepts from the book "Artificial Intelligence, a guide for thinking humans", by Melanie Mitchell.

License

Notifications You must be signed in to change notification settings

fau-masters-collected-works-cgarbin/machine-learning-but-not-understanding

Repository files navigation

Machine learning, but not understanding

This repository explores some of the concepts from the book "Artificial Intelligence, a guide for thinking humans", by Melanie Mitchell.

More specifically, it shows with some experiments that despite calling it "machine learning", the machines are not really "learning" in the sense that we, humans, use the term.

"Learning in neural networks simply consists in gradually modifying the weights on connections so that each output’s error gets as close to 0 as possible on all training examples."

(Quoted text blocks, like the one just above, are from Mitchell's book).

An important consequence of this "learning" process:

The machine learns what it observes in the data rather than what you (the human) might observe. If there are statistical associations in the training data, even if irrelevant to the task at hand, the machine will happily learn those instead of what you wanted it to learn.

The Jupyter notebook in this repository demonstrates how neural networks can fail because they are not in fact "learning".

If you are interested only in the concepts, see this blog post.

Exploring the concepts with code

To explore the concepts with code, configure the Python environment as described below, then open this Jupyter notebook.

Setting up the Python environment

Install Python 3

The project uses Python 3.

Verify that you have Python 3.x installed: python --version should print Python 3.x.y. If it prints Python 2.x.y, try python3 --version. If that still doesn't work, please install Python 3.x before proceeding. The official Python download site is here.

From this point on, the instructions assume that Python 3 is installed as python3.

Cloning the repository

git clone https://github.com/fau-masters-collected-works-cgarbin/machine-learning-but-not-understanding.git

The repository is now in the directory machine-learning-but-not-understanding.

Creating a Python virtual environment

Execute these commands to create and activate a virtual environment for the project:

#  switch to the directory where the cloned repository is
cd machine-learning-but-not-understanding

python3 -m venv env
source env/bin/activate
# or in Windows: env\Scripts\activate.bat

Installing the dependencies

It's important to update pip first. Older pip versions fail to install Tensorflow.

pip install --upgrade pip
pip install -r requirements.txt

Running the code

jupyter lab machine_learning_but_not_understanding.ipynb

About

Are machines "learning" anything? This repository explores some of the concepts from the book "Artificial Intelligence, a guide for thinking humans", by Melanie Mitchell.

Topics

Resources

License

Stars

Watchers

Forks

Releases

No releases published

Packages

No packages published